A controversial proposal to demolish a building dating back to 1872 and rebuild all but the remaining front facade has sparked uproar.

People living nearby are worried about the site, despite Richmond Council planning committee’s decision to defer a decision for further consultation with the owner of the historic Fife Road property.

Members of Mortlake with East Sheen Society voiced concern over losing a historical landmark and neighbours questioned if demolition plans could lead to “another Trafalgar Road” scenario - where a homeowner bulldozed his 19th century home without permission.

Property owner Simon Wedgewood told objectors at a Thursday, October 13, planning meeting issues with the structure meant he had to demolish a lot of the existing building.

He said: “A core part of this decision [to buy the house] was a desire and sincere commitment to retain the property and renovate it in line with the consent [I had].

“Once work on site commenced in November it became evident there were major structural problems.

“I understand at this time all the professionals are in agreement and there’s only one way forward.”

He said the application to demolish more than originally planned had been held up, partly by “the very different Trafalgar Road situation and resultant weariness in the planning department”, but said he was aware of local community concerns.

Mirielle Stanton, chairman of Mortlake with East Sheen Society, told the meeting parts of the house had already been demolished and were lost for good.

She said: “It’s an attractive subordinate building to the main house with its original detailing, chimneys and gables, brick work etc, but about 70 per cent of the original house has already gone [and] all that’s left is some of the roof the facade and wall.

“It is one of the oldest and most attractive buildings in Fife Road and contributes a great deal to the character and street scenes. To lose any more of the building would be most undesirable.”